Guess I should've felt something when he said it
Guess my heart should've leapt right out of my chest
Guess I should've known that he meant it
But maybe Im just numb instead

My heart was broken a long, long time ago
Shattered into pieces
But how could you have known?
Handed my heart right over on a silver platter
While he sat on a golden throne
Lookin' up at him, it never really mattered
Now I realize I'm so damn accident prone

Guess I should've felt something when he said it
Guess my heart should've leapt right out of my chest
Guess I should've known that he meant it
But maybe I'm just numb instead

I trust you, dont get me wrong
Im just so afraid to let you in
Scared I'll put my big foot in it
And we'll be over even before we begin