Can you make the movie better, please?

November 30, 2009
insertcleverscreennamehere SILVER, Loveland, Ohio
8 articles 0 photos 0 comments

Favorite Quote:
"It is not possible to live without failing at something, unless you live so cautiously you might as well have not lived at all, in which case you fail by default"-J.K. Rowling

"Hogwarts will always be there to welcome you home."-J.K. Rowling


A lot of movie today are based on books. These movies are usually very popular, probably because people who have read the book want to see the movie. But a lot of movies based on books really mess up the story. For example, the Harry Potter movies. There was a lot of important details left out of the movies that where in the books. I have a list of more than 25 things that are wrong with the 6th Harry Potter movie, such as the characters Bill and Charlie Weasley have never been in any of the movies even though they are in the 4th, 5th, 6th and 7th books, or the fact that Death Eaters move around in balls of smoke in the movies even though that is not in the books. Another example of a popular book/movie series is the Twilight series. That movie did do a lot better on not leaving stuff out, but there was one important thing left out, the scene where Bella says she hates the smell of blood.
Everyone who I've discussed this with agrees with me. The book is almost always better than the movie. So my question is why do people make movies out of books and then make the movies so different than the books? And why do the writers of the books let them? Making the movie like the book is not that hard! I've read novelizations of movies that weren't based on books, and those have had everything in the movie word for word. So why can't it be the same way when it's going from a book to a movie?


Similar Articles

JOIN THE DISCUSSION

This article has 2 comments.


guiarchick<3 said...
on Dec. 9 2009 at 9:16 am
I totally agree. It's the same thing with the twilight movies and the movie Marley & Me and probly tons of other based-on-book movies

on Dec. 8 2009 at 11:12 pm
Scripted BRONZE, Calgary, Other
3 articles 0 photos 17 comments

Favorite Quote:
"We walk by faith, not by sight"

I agree with you that the books are better than the movies. Books are filled with detail, a lot of it irrelevant only to fill pages. Movies summarize the books and are made to appeal to those who have not read the books. Bill and Charlie are minor characters and do not need a role in the movies. The fact that Death Eaters move around in balls is irrelevant. It is magical and is made to maximize entertainment. Movies cannot have everything the book does or it would be a 6 hour film. Look at Lord of the Rings. There is so much information that is in the book that is not shown in the movies. Should I complain? No. The information is irrelevant to the main plot of the story. Personally I think the conversion to the big screen from LOTR was very well done though a lot of events were slightly changed or missed. Keep in mind, when the movie is being made the author of the book is present and critiques and has a major voice in what happens. If it shows up in a movie the author has approved it.


SciArc

MacMillan Books

Aspiring Writer? Take Our Online Course!