Our Government vs. The Hunger Games Government

September 13, 2010
By Katherine G. BRONZE, Kansas City, Missouri
Katherine G. BRONZE, Kansas City, Missouri
2 articles 0 photos 0 comments

Does the government control everything? Maybe not as much in the United States, how ever in other societies and Panem they definitely do. Panem takes to extreme the punishment, violence and secrets where as the United States tries to keep it fair. Although, the government in the Hunger Games is different from the United States it is also very alike.

Not only do the Panem citizens have to work to stay alive but they also have a government that won’t tell them anything. Panem and the US both have censorship. In Panem the people know nothing about their government, society or what happens behind closed doors. All they know is what they see and what they manage to find out. Their whole life they grope to find out something but that gets them punished. It is sometimes the same in the US but isn’t as extreme. In the United States the government sometimes doesn’t tell the people some serious issues to avoid havoc. If the people knew everything they would be completely uncivilized because everybody would get worried at an unserious issue that can be resolved easily. So all societies have censorship but some of them have more of it. Panem is very extreme when it comes to that.

All societies have punishment when it comes to committing crimes. In Panem one of the punishments for a bad crime is becoming an Avox. When somebody becomes an Avox the government chops off their tongue so they can’t talk and then they have to serve the government. Also, in the Hunger Games punishment is violence. Violence could be a public whipping for hunting inside of the district or even being beat to death for hunting outside of the district. The government also maims citizens. A bad US punishment is going to jail for life or the death penalty. In the USA, for a small punishment they can also just give somebody a fine. If somebody gets too many driving tickets they can suspend your license. Those are some of the many punishments between the two societies. The US and the Hunger Games both have punishment but the Hunger Games society is much more extreme.

A difference between the two societies is that in the Hunger Games, the government controls everything. In the US there is freedom of speech and also people have lots of rights. Some of the rights include, the freedom of thought and speech, the freedom of life, the freedom of liberty, etc. In the Hunger Games the government controls their lives and doesn’t allow freedom of speech. The only time they can say something bad about the government is when they are deep into the woods where nobody can hear. Also, if a person living in the Hunger Games does something that the government feels is insulting them, the citizen will get a punishment depending on how bad it is. In the United States people can say whatever they want whenever they want. It is also a democracy so people can vote on decisions. The government doesn’t decide everything but they do make most of the decisions. It is fair and democratic where as the Hunger Games government is unfair and cruel.

The laws are also very different between the different societies. In Panem the laws are basically, don’t leave the district, no hunting and follow no rebellion. These laws are like the government itself which is, unfair and cruel. In the United States some of the laws include, no murdering, no suicide, no stealing, etc. The US’s laws are fair and simple. Depending on the states, the laws change. Panem can relate to other country’s laws but when it comes to the United States they are completely opposite.

Is the US on their way to a government like Panem? With the government we have now, maybe not anytime soon but what will it be like in a few years? American citizens should keep working to keep a fair government so it can stay that way for generations to come. Just as Panem’s citizens are trying to make their government better, so too American citizens also work on improving theirs. Hopefully Panem will revert back to the government we have now.



Similar Articles

JOIN THE DISCUSSION

This article has 9 comments.


on Sep. 16 2012 at 10:05 am
Jon Hollis BRONZE, Atlanta, Georgia
2 articles 0 photos 13 comments
Um...not quite. It had a lot of rash comparisons.

JCMerak BRONZE said...
on Sep. 9 2012 at 11:05 pm
JCMerak BRONZE, Reno, Ohio
3 articles 0 photos 10 comments
Good article but I do disagree with your comparisons. It seems as if our society itself does not know their own government. There are far more nefarious activities that governments both take part in or instigate, and for anyone to believe the media, or the so-called modern democratic process of concensus based outcomes, and the nearly total surveillance state that is created by millions of CCTV, red light cameras, car black boxes, GPS, cellular triangulation, biometrics, etc., etc.; it would be a crazy notion to ignore what is right in front of you. The only reason someone would compare the United States to Panem would be because the movie shows the scary version of ourselves; although truth is often stranger than fiction. Take a look at DARPA or the NSA and you've got a veritable compilation of technological and privacy nightmares. I digress though, although I have one more point to make. Look up the Latin phrase, "Panem et Circences". You will find its translation to be: Bread and Circuses. Follow the trail and read the true and underlying message: We are all living in a circus created and planned for by governments and we keep ourselves fed by the mind-numbing loaf. Sorry if this is critical, but there are opposing views to the "official story."

rroland GOLD said...
on May. 17 2012 at 7:29 pm
rroland GOLD, Cazenovia, New York
12 articles 0 photos 20 comments

Favorite Quote:
We except the love we think we deserve

it tottaly makes sense and is awsome GOOD JOB

on Oct. 22 2011 at 4:46 pm
Laura_Oliver GOLD, Manchester, Connecticut
12 articles 2 photos 122 comments

I have an autographed copy of the Hunger Games because I live in Connecticut. Ha!

Good piece, strong opinions.

 


on Nov. 26 2010 at 9:55 am
jalsaied SILVER, Fort Irwin, California
6 articles 0 photos 8 comments

Favorite Quote:
It is better to remain silent and be thought a fool than to open one's mouth and remove all doubt.
- Abraham Lincoln

This comparative piece is really good at outlining the world of the Hunger Games and ours. Great Job!

akacopycat said...
on Oct. 16 2010 at 4:17 am
Well done! I agree with everything you say hehehe ^_^

on Sep. 17 2010 at 8:36 am
LilSarah BRONZE, Kansas City, Missouri
2 articles 0 photos 5 comments

Favorite Quote:
None

I agree emily12321

on Sep. 17 2010 at 8:34 am
emily12321 BRONZE, Kansas City, Missouri
1 article 0 photos 2 comments

Favorite Quote:
"The best way to predict the future is to create it."- Abraham Lincoln

Great Job Katherine!!!!

on Sep. 17 2010 at 8:31 am
LilSarah BRONZE, Kansas City, Missouri
2 articles 0 photos 5 comments

Favorite Quote:
None

Oh my gosh it's so good!!!!

Good job Katherine G!!!



Parkland Book