Magazine, website & books written by teens since 1989

That Was Then This Is Now

Custom User Avatar
More by this author
“That Was Then, This Is Now,” is a 1971 novel written by S.E. Hinton. It was written by Hinton while she was experiencing three years of writers block. The book shares several characters with her previous book,”The Outsiders.” She has created a diverse group of characters, all of which seem realistic” ” However unlike, “The Outsiders,” the novel has a weak plot and a sour ending” She has created a diverse group of characters, all which seem realistic. However unlike, “The Outsiders,” the novel has a weak plot and a sour ending. The novel follows two best friends, Bryan and Mark, whom have a brotherly relationship. They have been synchronized their whole life, but Bryan begins to see the atrocities of the violence and drugs in the neighbor hood and Mark views it as a part of life. “A gap the size as the Gulf of Mexico,” diverges in their relationship.

Hinton fabricated a uniquely diverse set of characters. Bryan is the antagonist whom under goes a change of maturity (going from a hoodlum-like kid, to a sensible young man.) Mark is completely static as he desires a life on the streets and doesn't see anything wrong with violence or drugs. Kathy (Bryan's girlfriend) foils Mark. Kathy is a good girl and with high morals, mother-like qualities, and an admiration for her brother M&M. M&M is Kathy's younger brother and was friends with Bryan's and Mark previous to their relationship. According to the book M&M views the world with a child's innocence, but is gullible. It was enticing to see how Hinton kept some of the same characters from, “The Outsiders,” but still maintained their personalities. For example, Tim and Curly Shepard were still the leaders of the gang. Tim was still the tougher one and Curly remained his side kick. Poneyboy was in the novel as well it is implied that he is to be infatuated with Kathy, showing that he still admires the, “good girls,” opposed to the greasy broads.

The plot isn't as strong as Hinton's previous books. The rising actions are of Mark bringing home mysterious sums of money, Bryan dating Kathy, M&M running away, and Bryan getting jumped by the Shepard brothers. All of the following bring tension into Bryan and Marks relationship, the book at this point it relatively slow pace. Then M&M was found in a hippie house with a bad reaction to LSD, and then Mark is arrested for dealing drugs. It is almost as if there are two climaxes as the book suddenly became chaotic.

The resolving actions are depressing and make you want to bawl, however that is what S.E. Hinton intended. In the end the friendship between Bryan and Mark is completely broken, and makes the story seem depressing. It ends with such bitter emotions that in the 1985 motion picture on the novel the end was manipulated to make it appear more Hollywood friendly. A more joyful ending could have made it a storey of triumph and friendship. The events prior to the ending are so sad that the ending leaves a bitter taste in your mouth. If the book ended joyfully the plot could have greatly improved. Thou it as Hinton's vision for the book to end on a sour note, most people would have preferred a positive ending.

In Conclusion, “That Was Then This Is Now,” is a metiocre read for teen audiences. It has amazing and dynamic characters. Unfortunately the books lacks plot and a satisfying ending. The storey is recommended to fans of her previous book, “The Outsiders,” but be warned, I won't be as well done.



Join the Discussion

This article has 3 comments. Post your own now!

cllf said...
Mar. 23, 2013 at 10:33 pm
Antagonist is a person/group who goes against the main charcter Bryon is the 'protagonist' the protagonist is the main character of a story. 
 
XoxO said...
Nov. 19, 2009 at 2:36 pm
well missy, i thought the book was perfectly fine the way it was so there:)
and personally i loveeed the ending, with the whole ''but an old friend once told me, that was then this is now''
just my opinion :)
 
ssoo said...
Oct. 13, 2009 at 8:35 pm
this is a graet detailed essay
 
Site Feedback