The Triad of Fantasy Literature: Harry Potter, Twilight, and the Vampire Diaries

January 24, 2010
By abraggrep BRONZE, Brooksville, Florida
abraggrep BRONZE, Brooksville, Florida
4 articles 0 photos 0 comments

In pop culture today, everyone has heard of the seemingly amazing series, Twilight, by Stephenie Meyer. First being published in 2005, her vampire series has revived the era of vampires and given fresh blood (no pun intended) to the world of fantasy literature. Or has it?

Though Twilight has captured the hearts of even the most unromantic teenage girls, this piece of supposed literature is underdeveloped and hypocritical at best. Though Meyer’s Mormon beliefs can be felt subtly in all four of the books, most teenagers and their parents have not stopped to consider that though it can send great messages, Twilight also promotes finding a “perfect” and deadly man, as well as teenage marriage.

Many people today have called Stephenie Meyer the new J.K. Rowling, paving the way for a new generation of fantasy readers. But, is this acclaim for Meyer fair? Rowling wrote the Harry Potter series for seventeen years, winning numerous awards for her creativity and innovation. She wove together a new world that has enchanted children and adults alike to read more, while showing them life lessons and morals. Meyer, on the other hand, has only been innovative in the location of her vampires. Her world exists in the real world, and her conflict of vampires versus vampires, vampires versus werewolves, and vampires loving humans is not new. Even Robert Pattinson, the beloved Edward in the Twilight movies, was borrowed from Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire, the movie that escalated his acting career and without which he would not be in Twilight today. In fact, many of the “creative” things Meyer has expressed in her books resonate almost exactly in The Vampire Diaries by L.J. Smith, written about fifteen years before Twilight.

Critics today speak of the new television show, The Vampire Diaries, as if it has stolen the thunder from the popular Twilight. But has it really? The Vampire Diaries is based off of a series by the same name, which tells the story of vampire Stefan Salvatore, his “evil” brother, and the love of Stefan’s life, Elena. While many argue that the fact that the conflict is between two brother vampires, not a vampire and werewolf, the same ideas appear in both Twilight and Vampire Diaries. The human girl fascinated by the mysterious vampire. The vampire who’s lust for her love and lust for her blood causes more complications than at first glance. The other man who tries everything in his power to win the girl’s heart. The similarities between the series are above coincidence.

Some religious groups today banish Harry Potter for its witchcraft and The Vampire Diaries for its evilness. Many teenagers even flock to Twilight for solace. However, this belief that both series are evil is not just wrong, it is hypocritical. Harry Potter tells of the battle between good and evil, in which good triumphs in the end. This same struggle is apparent in The Chronicles of Narnia, which even includes magic, but Narnia is still found in Christian bookstores. If those who ban Harry Potter were to read the series, they may be surprised at its good morals and messages, as well as its indirect link between the struggles in the Bible between Jesus and the Romans and the struggles in the series between Harry and Lord Voldemort. As for The Vampire Diaries, the same struggle of good versus evil leads to the triumph of good. Other questionable content in both series is nonexistent. Not so in Twilight.

In New Moon, Bella tries her hand at extreme sports, risking suicide just to hear Edward’s voice. In later chapters, Edward attempts suicide several times in a special, vampire way, all because he believes Bella died. In Eclipse, Bella tries everything in her power to convince Edward to have sex with her, the only thing her mind focuses on. Edward only refuses to do so because he could hurt her. Instead, his bargain is for her to marry him, something Bella refuses to do or even consider. She only agrees when her becoming a vampire becomes part of the wager. In Breaking Dawn, Bella marries Edward at nineteen, and then becomes pregnant weeks later. This promotes not only teenage marriage, but teenage pregnancy. So much for Twilight being Christian and well-written.

The author's comments:
This piece was inspired by the craze that is Twilight. Many will disagree with this piece, but that is what makes it an opinion.

Similar Articles

JOIN THE DISCUSSION

This article has 11 comments.


on Dec. 30 2014 at 12:00 am
Thefanatasticagirlie101 SILVER, Euless, Texas
6 articles 0 photos 62 comments

Favorite Quote:
"The best love is the kind that awakens the soul; that makes us reach for more, that plants the fire in our hearts and brings peace to our mind. That's what I hope to give you forever." ~The Notebook

Preach on, Preach on.... TVD Rules!!!!!

on Aug. 30 2012 at 5:32 pm
Luckystar78 ELITE, London, Other
114 articles 0 photos 97 comments

Favorite Quote:
"..though warm as summer it was fresh as spring." (Thomas Hardy) ("Far from the Madding crowd")

Harry Potter forever...Twilight: never!

on Jun. 29 2012 at 6:11 pm
ClarinetPower SILVER, Macomb, Michigan
5 articles 0 photos 40 comments
So true about Christianity and Twilight!

on Jan. 11 2012 at 9:37 am
skyaroundtheworld BRONZE, Utica, Pennsylvania
1 article 0 photos 5 comments

Favorite Quote:
"The world is a book and those who travel read just one page"

Why was this not published in the mag?! This is one of the best articles I have read on here. You did a great job with this and I agree. I enjoy Twilight but it is not OMG THE BEST THING EVER! Vampire Diaries came first and, quite honestly, it is better - or at least the show is better than the movies. Great job on this!

on Jul. 14 2011 at 11:20 pm

Finally someone who agrees!

My dad didn't want me reading Harry Potter until I explained to him, that its all about the battle between good and  evil, and as long as you believe it as fantasy it okay.

 

Plus, TVD is extremely better written than twilight (Characters, scenes, descriptions) And its just more real

1. What can I say about the characters? Elena is badass,( not soppy and cheating like Bella,) Damon is the bad boy.(no ' Love me because i take my shirt  off all the time!') Stefan is protective but cool (No stalking her and talking as it he has marbles up his nostrils)

 

2.The Vampires and werewolves are so much better and cooler in TVD,

 

3. a PROPER love triangle :)

 

4. PROPER baddies (KAtherine & Klaus!)

 

 

The Cullens are not vampires. They are sparkly faries :)

 

GO SALVATORES!  :D


on Mar. 25 2011 at 10:24 pm
I could not agree more. I've fowarded this to my friends too. I'm always talking like this too. I have no want to read Twilight, noo real conflict, just trying to get some girl's heart. Harry Potter was brilliant, and now I want to read Vampire Diaries too.

on Mar. 24 2011 at 3:13 pm
The article is very good, I believe that religion doesn´t have to mess with the literaturesince it would be very hypocritical, it's true what they say about twilight that promotesadolescent marriage and stuff but we must not forget that Harry Potter can make aperfect comparison with the Nazis and Hitler and passed specifically to explain why: Voldemort was of mixed race and during his government (2 governments) kkilled "muggles" and "mestizos" and did the same thing Hitler killed Jews and people of otherraces when he was a Jew. It seems completely hypocritical that Harry Potter is sold inChristian stores taking into account what I said above, another thing I do not understandis that Christians are "ousted" both the Twilight saga whether they actually are doingwhat Christianity wants: a virgin at marriage and do not use condoms, which the pope said in Africa knowingthat millions of people die from AIDS or other diseases, whether sexual transimición orbad conditions, I now wonder not, because religion rather than mess with the literature isnot an issue for what it does, why not sell the treasures of the Vatican and cure global poverty rather than emppezar to criticize the writers?I clarified that there are no problems, my name is Victoria, I'm from Argentina and I have15 years and im a huge fan of Twilight, Vampire Diaries and Harry Potter. (sorry for my bad English in some words I had to use the Google translator. 
saludos desde Argentina para todos\as. <3

Coffee BRONZE said...
on Dec. 15 2010 at 6:52 pm
Coffee BRONZE, Tallahassee, Florida
4 articles 5 photos 184 comments

Favorite Quote:
Your Face.

Icompeletely agre.I see no relious things wrong with Harry potter,my self. So what if there are witches and wizards? it's called FANTASY after all,so what are people supposed to write about then? I can't stand twilight, the character are totally stupid and Bella falls for a guywho's creepy looking, sparkley, and watches her while she sleeps..(does no one else find that a little bit creepy?)Harry Potter is one of my favorite series. I agree with everyword you said. (is it justme,or do morewriters dislike twilight then like it?Iguess it would make sense)

on Dec. 8 2010 at 12:22 pm
Delanafan4ever BRONZE, Columbus, Ohio
3 articles 0 photos 25 comments

Favorite Quote:
Never give in, Never back down

Yes TEAM DELENA 4ever!

on Mar. 17 2010 at 5:28 pm
Ashleigh909 GOLD, Buford, Georgia
14 articles 0 photos 12 comments

Favorite Quote:
"The night is the darkest just before the dawn."

I totally agree. i mean, sure Stephenie says that her books are completley orginal and that she hasn't seen buffy and angel and read TVD, but HELLO? Stefan Salvatore just HAPPENS to drive a Porsche 911 Turbo? Coincidence? Very unlikely. And Damon actually tries his best not to let any feeling for Elena show, meanwhile, Jacob is falling head over heels for a marrie gilrl. Desperate much? Team Edward? No. Team JAcob? No. Team DELENA FORVER!!!!! Uh... YES!

on Jan. 31 2010 at 8:16 pm
Jack_Walton SILVER, Gray, Tennessee
6 articles 1 photo 44 comments

Favorite Quote:
In a mad world, only the mad are sane. - Akira Kurosawa

Exactly...


SciArc

MacMillan Books

Aspiring Writer? Take Our Online Course!